Funding must work better for SMEs to tackle energy challenges finds research

Scotland’s small food and drink businesses face significant financial and operational barriers that could see them frozen out of vital funding to cut emissions from keeping produce cold, according to research from Heriot-Watt University.
Produced with partners including the Scotland Food & Drink Partnership’s Net Zero Programme and the Scottish Wholesale Association, the report calls for a coordinated approach involving businesses, government, financial institutions and industry bodies.
The study focuses on the food cold chain, which keeps produce fresh from farm to fridge and is fundamental to getting food to Scotland’s communities, hospitality and food service businesses, and public service providers.
We need a more joined-up approach that combines accessible finance with practical business support and industry collaboration. Industry bodies can play a vital role in connecting SMEs with funding opportunities, facilitating collective action and sharing expertise, helping businesses cut emissions and energy costs while strengthening their long-term competitiveness.
Professor Bing Xu
Director of the Centre for Financing a Sustainable Future at Heriot-Watt University’s Edinburgh Business School
Professor Bing Xu, Director of the Centre for Financing a Sustainable Future at Heriot-Watt University’s Edinburgh Business School, said: “Scotland’s food industry puts quality produce on our tables every day. But keeping that produce cold uses a lot of energy, around the clock.
“Upgrading refrigeration often requires substantial upfront investment. For SMEs, this can put significant pressure on cash flow, particularly in the current economic climate when businesses face competing financial priorities.
“The challenge is not simply a lack of finance, but a mismatch between available funding and the investment needs of SMEs. Businesses may struggle to identify suitable support and make decarbonisation commercially viable.
“We need a more joined-up approach that combines accessible finance with practical business support and industry collaboration. Industry bodies can play a vital role in connecting SMEs with funding opportunities, facilitating collective action and sharing expertise, helping businesses cut emissions and energy costs while strengthening their long-term competitiveness.”

Small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) make up around 95% of Scotland’s food and drink sector.
The report highlights that achieving net zero requires more than technological innovation and access to finance.
Businesses also have an important role to play in improving energy efficiency, reducing waste and embedding sustainability into their operations and supply chains.
Aligning these business-led initiatives with appropriate financing strategies, industry collaboration and supportive policies can help accelerate decarbonisation while delivering long-term economic and environmental benefits.
While many firms can see the potential benefits of investing in cleaner technologies and more sustainable practices, high upfront costs, uncertain returns and competing business priorities can make investment difficult.
Accessing suitable finance and developing internal capabilities needed to plan and implement investments can present additional challenges, particularly for SMEs.
The report recommends grants and low-cost finance designed for SMEs, with industry bodies able to apply for funding on behalf of groups of firms.
Simon McKeating, Partnerships Manager for the Scotland Food & Drink Partnership Net Zero Commitment Programme, said: “Our climate transition plan, is clear that the challenge is no longer knowing what to do, but making it happen.
“Financial constraints are the biggest barrier the sector faces, and small firms feel that most, particularly in rural and island communities.
“This research gives us evidence from businesses on the ground about what would help, from simpler routes to funding to trusted, practical advice. It’s exactly the kind of collaboration between industry and academia we need to turn the plan into action.”
The study forms part of the Zero-Emission Cold-Chain (ZECC) project, funded by the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC). Led by Dr Xinfang Wang at the University of Birmingham, it brings together Heriot-Watt, Cranfield and London South Bank universities to build cleaner, more resilient food cold chains.
Over 2025 to 2026, researchers held workshops and interviews with Scottish food producers and wholesalers. They also carried out six in-depth case studies, ranging from family-run producers to island wholesalers.
The research follows the launch of Scotland’s Food and Drink Climate Transition Plan from earlier this month. Developed by the Scotland Food & Drink Partnership, the plan sets out priority actions for government and industry to help the £19 billion sector meet Scotland’s legally binding 2045 net zero target.
Ylva Haglund, Head of Sustainability & Communications at the Scottish Wholesale Association, said: “The findings from the Heriot-Watt research really chime with what we've been hearing from our members. Wholesalers want to invest in decarbonisation, but upfront costs and wider commercial pressures remain significant barriers.
“We need practical financial support, greater recognition of wholesale in investment programmes, and a policy environment that gives businesses the confidence to invest in a more efficient and resilient food supply chain.”
The report highlights that most cold chain emissions come not from refrigerant gas leaks, as is often assumed, but from the energy needed to run compressors, chillers and freezers around the clock. For smaller firms, the energy bill and the carbon footprint are the same problem.
Most of the firms studied invested in low-carbon refrigeration only when it also brought another benefit, such as lower costs, reduced risk, compliance or meeting customer demands.
Firms that upgrade to meet one major customer’s demands also risk a “stranded investment” if that customer later changes supplier.
The report treats practical training and support as just as important as closing the funding gap. It also argues public money should take the risk out of early investment to draw in private capital.
It recommends that industry bodies set up shared platforms bringing together training, data, market insight and best practice.
For firms ready to act now, the report suggests starting small, with savings from energy efficiency and cutting waste used to fund further upgrades.